With Maddie's school's career day approaching, Ben puts the job hunt into high gear; Kate develops a crush on her neighbor; B.J. faces backlash for receiving a pay raise.
B.J. tries to help Kate loosen up at a neighbor's Halloween party; Tommy and Ben hand out candy to trick-or-treaters in hope of meeting attractive moms.
Will encourages Kate to go to her high school reunion and confront a bully; Ben worries he can't keep his and B.J.'s secret from Kate much longer.