When Eddie sees the photos of himself and Joy having a great time in Italy, he is reminded of how the vacation ended. In order to make things right, Eddie does all he can to relive their trip to Italy right there in the suburbs of Philadelphia.
The guys learn that Jeff never had a bachelor party, leading them to plan a boys night at a nightclub. But when Nicole tags along with Cofeld, the night does not go as planned.
Eddie and Joy share a dorm room with a partying single father when they visit Allison for parents' weekend; Jeff hires someone to help Steph tile the bathroom.